Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies Program on Energy and Sustainable Development Stanford University


Publications




What context features might be important determinants of the effectiveness of patient safety practice interventions?

Journal Article

Authors
Taylor SL, Dy S, Foy R, Hempel S, Kathryn M. McDonald, Ovretveit J, Pronovost PJ, Rubenstein LV, Wachter RM, Shekelle PG

Published by
BMJ Quality and Safety, Vol. 20 no. 7, page(s) 611-7
2011


Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Differences in contexts (eg, policies, healthcare organisation characteristics) may explain variations in the effects of patient safety practice (PSP) implementations. However, knowledge of which contextual features are important determinants of PSP effectiveness is limited and consensus is lacking on a taxonomy of which contexts matter.

METHODS:

Iterative, formal discussions were held with a 22-member technical expert panel composed of experts or leaders in patient safety, healthcare systems, and methods. First, potentially important contextual features were identified, focusing on five PSPs. Then, two surveys were conducted to determine the context likely to influence PSP implementations.

RESULTS:

The panel reached a consensus on a taxonomy of four broad domains of contextual features important for PSP implementations: safety culture, teamwork and leadership involvement; structural organisational characteristics (eg, size, organisational complexity or financial status); external factors (eg, financial or performance incentives or PSP regulations); and availability of implementation and management tools (eg, training organisational incentives). Panelists also tended to rate specific patient safety culture, teamwork and leadership contexts as high priority for assessing their effects on PSP implementations, but tended to rate specific organisational characteristic contexts as high priority only for use in PSP evaluations. Panelists appeared split on whether specific external factors and implementation/management tools were important for assessment or only description.

CONCLUSION:

This work can guide research commissioners and evaluators on the contextual features of PSP implementations that are important to report or evaluate. It represents a first step towards developing guidelines on contexts in PSP implementation evaluations. However, the science of context measurement needs maturing.